Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs

Experience authentic NY-style pizza, flavorful subs, garlic knots, and fresh salads at Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs in Venice, FL. Family-owned with delicious marinara, eggplant parm, and more. Call +1 941-408-9226!

Welcome to Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs

Taste the Difference.

Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs
Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs
Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs
Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs

Located at 2085 S Tamiami Trl in Venice, FL, Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs offers a cozy atmosphere for anyone craving authentic NY style pizza. This family-owned establishment brings a slice of New York to the Gulf Coast, serving up mouthwatering pizzas and subs that transport diners straight to the streets of Brooklyn. With a reputation built on quality and community, Mama Maria's is not only about food; it’s about creating lasting memories around the table. Whether you're stopping by for lunch or dinner, the aromas wafting from this lively pizzeria promise to tantalize your taste buds.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

2085 S Tamiami Trl, Venice, FL 34293, United States

Phone

+1 941-408-9226

About

The Culinary Story

Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs
Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs
Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs
Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs

Mama Maria's is more than just a restaurant; it's a cornerstone of the Venice community. The pizzeria reflects the heart and soul of its owners, who aim to deliver an experience that transcends dining. With roots in New York pizza culture, Mama Maria's prides itself on authenticity. Every pizza is handcrafted, with dough made fresh daily.

Diners rave about the marinara sauce, especially paired with the legendary garlic knots that beckon to be dipped. The family-oriented atmosphere welcomes everyone, from the casual diner to families celebrating special occasions. Mama Maria's isn't just a spot to eat; it's a gathering place where laughter and the rich aroma of tomato sauce and melting cheese fill the room.

In addition to classic pizza offerings, Mama Maria’s stands out with its impressive selection of subs, including the pastrami and meatball varieties that locals can't stop talking about.

The menu also boasts robust calzones loaded with fresh ingredients, all while upholding a commitment to quality and community connection. Regular customers know each other's names, creating a network of friendships forged over shared plates of cheesy goodness and flavorful subs.

The passionate team behind the pizzeria actively engages with the community, often partnering with local events and initiatives.

This dedication extends beyond serving food; it embodies the essence of support and unity within Venice. Whether you’re a longtime local or a first-time visitor, stepping into Mama Maria’s promises a warm welcome, a delicious meal, and an unyielding sense of belonging.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday3:30-8 PM
  • Monday11 AM-8 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8:30 PM

Mama Maria's features a diverse menu that attracts locals and visitors alike. Signature dishes include crispy garlic knots, the robust meatball parm sub, and the comforting eggplant parm. Each creation is made fresh in-house, ensuring every dish bursts with flavor. The pizzeria also caters to various appetites with salads like the classic Greek, alongside hearty calzones and scrumptious steak and cheese subs.

The homey setting offers both indoor seating and patio options, where friends and families can enjoy meals in a friendly, welcoming environment that feels like a home away from home.

Busiest times can be quite a spectacle, especially on Friday evenings, when the restaurant fills to capacity. Plan a visit during the quieter hours for a more relaxed dining experience. The lunchtime rush is lively, yet it can be more manageable early on weekdays.

Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs

Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs presents a charming façade that captures the spirit of a classic New York eatery. Bright signage greets hungry patrons, and the outdoor seating area provides a delightful spot for al fresco dining. Locals often reminisce about enjoying meals while basking in the Florida sunshine, capturing the essence of Miami's vibrant culinary culture. The lively atmosphere reflects a sense of community, characterized by friendly chatter and the smell of fresh pizza.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Great!! Super friendly. I'm on a little bit of a pizza tour right now for a one stop slice and I have to say this was so delicious and so worth every penny. The crust the sauce the cheese... can't wait to try a full one. If this is Boston pizza, this Chicago girl will definitely be coming back.

B
Britney H.

We ordered pizza to be delivered and it was wonderful. Service was speedy and the pizza was better than expected. Delivery guy was super sweet. And... the best part - it was affordable!!!

S
Sue E.

Out of many choices in the area, we found this gem online and were thrilled with our food, friendly service, and family restaurant. I had the spaghetti with mozzarella and she had the cheeseburger sub. Delicious! Family staff ensured everyone and everything were attended to. The place was very well attended also (Sunday early evening).

M
Mark M.

Experience Authentic Italian Flavors at Mama Maria's Pizzeria & Subs in Venice, FL If you're craving an unforgettable Italian dining experience, head straight to Mama Maria's Pizzeria & Subs in Venice, FL. Located at 2085 Tamiami Trail South, this beloved local eatery is your gateway to the rich and tantalizing flavors of Italy, right in your neighborhood. At Mama Maria's, every dish is a masterpiece. Their renowned hand-tossed pizzas, calzones, and subs are crafted to perfection. Picture biting into a crispy yet soft crust, topped with a perfectly balanced marinara sauce, high-quality cheese, and the freshest toppings. Whether you're a traditional Margherita lover or eager to try the daring Steak Bomb calzone, Mama Maria's promises a delightful culinary journey. What truly sets Mama Maria's apart is its exceptional service and cozy atmosphere. The friendly, attentive staff ensures that every visit feels special. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, expect a warm welcome and a delightful experience. The family-friendly, cozy ambiance at Mama Maria's makes it ideal for any occasion. Be it a quick lunch, a casual dinner with friends, or a special celebration, the welcoming environment enhances the overall dining experience. Enjoy Mama Maria's delicious offerings from the comfort of your home with their takeout and delivery options. With credit card acceptance and ample parking, convenience is guaranteed. Visit Mama Maria's Today! Discover the best of Italian cuisine at Mama Maria's Pizzeria & Subs. You'll leave with a satisfied stomach and a smile on your face. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 8:30 PM, Mama Maria's is ready to serve you the finest pizza and subs in Venice, FL.

T
TJ B.

Best pizza in Florida!!! We've been on both coasts and through Orlando...other than going to Italy...this is the best authentic pizza pre I've had in years!!! Across the state, around the globe, you can't beat the price, quality or service Mama Maria's Pizzeria is top on my list!! The best crust...crispy and chewy. The yummiest cheese...so perfectly gooey. Pepperoni like I remember from childhood Families are destined to find their new favorite hangout once they sit down and have that first piece of pie! Nee after movie hangout...here we come!!

M
MyOnline R.

We ordered from here late last night. Nothing from the norm because this is our absolute favorite go-to for pizza and Italian food! When my husband walked in to get the order last night and he was received with a " we made you the best antipasto ever!" In all my life, it absolutely is! This is what antipasto should be, and we are the number one fans of Mamma Maria's Pizzeria for many years and many to come.

A
AMANDA K.